People are driving off rather than talk to Burger King's robot

Hello!

Today we’re covering…

  • The two burger giants taking opposite sides of voice AI

  • Starbucks trimming its store count again

  • Cracker Barrel’s gradual comeback

Read on…

3 Numbers

-2.1%

Same-store sales drop for Cracker Barrel last quarter — an improvement from the dark winter days of the logo slump, when quarterly comps dropped 7.1%. Wall Street smells a comeback brewing; at Friday’s market close, the stock was up almost 93% year-to-date.

250

Underperforming locations that Starbucks is closing. This marks the second biggish store markdown under Brian Niccol’s leadership — last September Starbucks closed 627 stores in North America and Europe — but it’s still a relative drop in the bucket for the company, which currently owns and operates over 11,000 North American stores.

95%

C-store operators who call foodservice a strategic priority, according to a Technomic survey that was unveiled at the FSTEC conference last week. Another fun stat to keep restaurateurs up at night: 68% of consumers believe c-stores can match restaurants on providing fresh, quality food. (*Extremely Steve Ballmer voice* Hospitality, hospitality, hospitality, hospitality, hospitality, hospitality…)

The Big Story

Burger King is pushing back on the idea that drive-thru AI is inevitable (or at least that it’s imminent). Via Restaurant Business:

Burger King is pumping the brakes on drive-thru AI after finding that some customers don’t like ordering from a robot.

The burger chain, which has been testing AI voice ordering in the drive-thru for several years with Google and other partners, says it wants to make it easier for customers to order from a human employee if they want. 

“We quickly realized if we force [AI to be] the only way that you can order or interact with our brand, it doesn't go well,” Chakri Somisetti, Burger King’s vice president of brand technologies, said during a panel at the FSTEC conference Wednesday. “We've seen that in our pilot restaurants, there are drive offs because guests don't want to talk to a bot.”

BK is not completely killing the test — it will remain in 50 to 70 locations — but customers will be given a quick way to reach a human during their orders.

Meanwhile, McDonald’s is planning a broader rollout of Archy, its voice AI, via Restaurant Dive:

Archy can take orders in both English and Spanish and has accuracy above 90%, [McDonald’s CIO Brian] Rice said. 

“In our early test restaurants with Archy, drive-thru customer satisfaction is above national trends,” Rice said. “As Archy scales, it will free at least 50 labor hours per week. This is one of the most significant and tangible benefits of ArchIQ.”

Archy is live in 10 U.S. restaurants and has started in Australia. McDonald’s didn’t give too many details on when it will arrive in more stores, but it’s an integral part of a broader $8.5 billion modernization plan — so odds are, you’ll be talking to it sooner rather than later.

It’s rare to see direct rivals stake the exact opposite position on the same question… in the same week.

Burger King seems to be meeting its customers closer to where they currently are — at the FSTEC conference, Technomic presented data showing that drive-thru voice AI remains broadly unpopular; only 23% of consumers find it appealing. It ranked last of the six ordering methods they tested.

But McDonald’s could be skating to where the puck is going. If voice AI polls badly because respondents held earlier, clunkier versions in their mind’s eye, McDonald’s may be betting it can overcome doubters with today’s better tech (and its own ubiquity).

Technomic didn’t survey me, but if they did, I wouldn’t really know how to answer. I’ve had some actually helpful AI customer service “conversations.” I’ve had others that are so bad they left me repeating “speak with a representative, speak with a representative” like a deranged Howard Hughes.

For now, I tend to think the Burger King approach makes the most sense. Give people a fast toggle to a human, but keep testing the technology. Because at some point in the not-so-distant future, its benefits will be undeniable.

Elsewhere In the Headlines

Name That Chain!

You’ve got three clues to name this issue’s chain:

  • It began as two rival burger chains born a year apart in the 1980s with a similar idea — two drive-thru lanes, no dining room, and a limited menu.

  • The concepts merged in 1999. The parent company today is headquartered in Tampa and runs restaurants in 28 states and D.C.

  • Which sign you see today depends on which side of the Ohio River you happen to live on. (But its famous fries are served at all locations.)

Find the answer at the bottom of the email…

Power Moves

Here are some notable recent C-suite moves:

Thanks for reading! I’ll see you again next week.

NAME THAT CHAIN ANSWER: Checkers & Rally’s

Reply

or to participate.